Build vs Buy Search: What’s Right for Your Business?

Site search has evolved from a simple feature into a mission-critical capability for modern digital experiences. Whether you’re running an eCommerce store, a content-heavy platform, or a SaaS product, providing fast, relevant, and intelligent search is essential for user satisfaction and business growth.

However, when it comes to implementing a site search solution, most businesses eventually face the age-old dilemma: Build vs Buy Search. Should you develop your own in-house search engine tailored to your specific requirements, or should you invest in a pre-built solution from a third-party provider?

This blog dives into the technical, operational, and strategic factors to consider when choosing between building or buying a search solution and why Expertrec might be the optimal choice for businesses looking to strike the right balance between customization, speed, and ROI.

What Is Meant by Build vs Buy in Search?

Build: Building a search engine in-house means your engineering team takes full responsibility for designing, developing, deploying, and maintaining the entire search infrastructure. This includes indexing, querying, ranking, autocomplete, typo tolerance, faceting, analytics, scalability, and security.

Buy: Buying a search engine involves integrating a third-party search-as-a-service provider that offers a ready-to-use API or UI components. The provider handles all the backend complexity, allowing you to focus on content optimization and business logic.

Pros and Cons of Building Your Own Search

Pros:

• Full Control: You can tailor the ranking algorithms, UI behavior, and data handling to meet your exact business requirements.

• No Vendor Lock-in: You retain ownership of the architecture and are not dependent on a vendor’s roadmap or pricing changes.

• Deep Integration: Search can be tightly coupled with your business logic, personalization engines, and backend systems.

Cons:

• High Development Cost: Building a scalable search engine from scratch can take 6–12 months or longer. It requires experienced backend engineers, DevOps, and search engineers familiar with Elasticsearch, Solr, or similar technologies.

• Ongoing Maintenance: You’ll be responsible for patching bugs, improving relevance, handling traffic spikes, and maintaining SLAs.

• Hidden Costs: From infrastructure scaling to relevance tuning, the operational overhead can add up rapidly.

• Slower Time to Market: Building delays your go-live date and risks losing potential revenue or user engagement during that window.

Pros and Cons of Buying a Search Solution

Pros:

• Faster Implementation: You can deploy advanced search capabilities within days or weeks, not months.

• Lower Upfront Costs: No need to hire a full in-house team or provision dedicated servers.

• Advanced Features Out-of-the-Box: Most platforms offer typo tolerance, synonyms, ranking, analytics, filters, and AI-driven relevance from the get-go.

• Scalability and Reliability: Providers often offer high-availability hosting with SLA-backed uptime and performance.

• Continuous Innovation: You benefit from new features, security updates, and algorithm improvements without additional effort.

Cons:

• Less Control: Some platforms may limit customization or make it difficult to override default ranking behavior.

• Recurring Costs: Subscription-based pricing can add up, especially if you scale rapidly or have high search volumes.

• Vendor Dependency: If the provider goes out of business, changes APIs, or raises prices, migration can be difficult.

Build vs Buy: When to Choose What?

Is It Worth Building Your Own Search?

For enterprise companies with massive engineering resources and highly unique use cases (e.g., internal search at Google or Amazon), building an in-house search system might make sense. But for 95% of businesses, it’s rarely worth the cost, complexity, and time.

Search is not just about indexing and querying. Modern users expect:

• Personalized results

• Real-time autocomplete

• Natural language understanding

• Zero-results handling

• Analytics and A/B testing

• Mobile optimization

Developing and maintaining these features internally can turn your engineering team into a search company—which is rarely your core mission.

Why Expertrec is the Smarter Choice

If you’re leaning toward the “buy” side but need customization, reliability, and cost-effectiveness, Expertrec stands out as a compelling choice.

Here’s why:

1. No-Code Setup

Expertrec allows you to implement powerful search on your website without writing a single line of code. It’s especially helpful for non-technical teams.

2. Highly Customizable

Unlike other SaaS providers that limit your control, Expertrec gives you the freedom to customize ranking logic, UI/UX, filters, and more.

3. AI-Powered Relevance

Expertrec uses machine learning to continuously improve search relevance based on user behavior, boosting conversions and reducing bounce rates.

4. Lightning-Fast Performance

Pages load with sub-second search results, even at scale, thanks to distributed indexing and caching infrastructure.

5. Affordable Pricing

Expertrec offers cost-effective plans that make advanced search features accessible to small and medium businesses—not just enterprises.

6. Dedicated Support

Get direct access to support engineers who help you fine-tune and optimize your search experience to meet your business KPIs.

Book a Demo

Final Verdict: Build vs Buy Search

In today’s competitive digital landscape, delivering a fast, intelligent, and frictionless search experience isn’t optional—it’s essential. While building your own search may give you control, it comes at a high cost in terms of time, talent, and total ownership.

For most businesses, buying a search engine is the clear winner, offering faster ROI, lower TCO (Total Cost of Ownership), and peace of mind. But not all providers are created equal.

Expertrec bridges the gap between flexibility and ease. It gives you the power of a robust, AI-powered search engine with the simplicity of a plug-and-play setup—customized to your brand’s needs and optimized for conversions.

Book a Demo

FAQs